Legislative Report - 3/20/11

I am once again proud to be from a town that still holds a traditional Town Meeting, and I was privileged to afford Charlotters the opportunity to participate in the Doyle Poll, the survey that has been conducted for many decades by Senator Bill Doyle.  78 Charlotters filled out the survey this year.  Although the statewide results haven’t been published yet, here are the local results.




2011 Sen. Bill Doyle
Town Meeting Day Survey
YES
NO
Not sure
YES
NO
Not sure
1
Renew VY License?
28
39
11
35.9%
50.0%
14.1%
2
Prohibit Cell Phones while driving?
54
21
3
69.2%
26.9%
3.8%
3
Legalize Physician-Assisted Suicide?
51
19
8
65.4%
24.4%
10.3%
4
4-yr term for Governor?
44
25
9
56.4%
32.1%
11.5%
5
Mandatory min sentence for repeat DUI?
57
13
8
73.1%
16.7%
10.3%
6
Require VTers to buy health insurance?
32
34
12
41.0%
43.6%
15.4%
7
Confidence in Gov. Shumlin?
41
23
14
52.6%
29.5%
17.9%
8
Continue use of motorcycle helmets?
74
3
1
94.9%
3.8%
1.3%
9
Law enforcement use of tasers ok?
33
28
17
42.3%
35.9%
21.8%
10
Should legislature encourage bicycling & walking?
56
16
6
71.8%
20.5%
7.7%
11
Expand bottle bill to all bottled beverages?
58
15
5
74.4%
19.2%
6.4%
12
Willing to pay more for locally grown food?
54
18
6
69.2%
23.1%
7.7%
13
Willing to pay more for renewable energy?
43
27
8
55.1%
34.6%
10.3%



The House Natural Resources and Energy Committee finalized the Vermont Energy Bill of 2011 this week. It is a modest addition to our goal of moving Vermont to a sustainable and clean energy future. Some of the original elements were put on hold until several reports from the Dept. of Public Service, including a new state energy plan, and the Biomass Working Group are completed. The major provisions in the final version continue Vermont's emphasis on promoting efficiency, renewable energy, and jobs.  Net-Metering, which allows utility customers to get credit for renewable energy they generate, has been expanded allowing continued marketability for solar and wind businesses, thereby retaining the associated jobs and creating new jobs.   Funding of the Clean Energy Development Fund (CEDF) has been included by assessing a 55 cents/month surcharge on the utility bills of all utility customers starting 90 days after enactment.  This $6.60-per-year increase will sunset in 2014.  By that time an alternate source of funding can be found.   Another provision in the bill sets standards for reducing the sulfur content of home heating oil and for increasing biodiesel content. Implementation of the standards is contingent on adoption of similar standards by surrounding states since Vermont is not a large enough market to require implementation by itself. The new standards, which take effect gradually between 2012 and 2018, will reduce the sulfur content of emissions and improve the efficiency of oil furnaces of our homes and businesses.

Everyone is talking about the Single-payer Health Care bill (H.202) and whether it will truly achieve the goals set by Gov. Shumlin.  I am hoping to hold a public forum in a couple of weeks to discuss the provisions in the bill so that people can form their opinions based on facts rather than rumors.  The date, time and place will be publicized via posters, Front Porch Forum and my website a week or two ahead.

I am continuing to hold “Meet Your Representative” sessions every second and fourth Monday of the month from to and from to at the Town office.  I invite you to stop by and share your thoughts and opinions about your concerns.  You can also contact me by phone at 425-3960 or email me at myantachka.dfa@gmail.com. 

Q&A re H.202 VERMONT'S UNIFIED HEALTH CARE BILL

H.202 House Health Care Amendment
Questions and Answers
Q. Why do we need health care reform?
·        The cost of the status quo is too high is growing at an unsustainable rate—our current system will bankrupt us if we don’t act to control costs.
o       Vermont’s health care costs are rising by $1million per day and are growing 12 times faster than the State’s economy.  Costs have doubled since 2006.  In 2012, health care for Vermont residents will cost nearly $6 billion.
o       Families with private insurance pay an average of $5,000 per year in out-of-pocket healthcare costs, not including premiums. That is unsustainable for Vermont families, business and economy.
o       Studies show that most bankruptcies are caused by health problems and medical bills.
o        More than 47,000 Vermonters are uninsured and as many as another 90,000 are underinsured.  That’s more than one quarter of the state’s population vulnerable to the danger that one major illness could cause them to lose everything.
o       As a result, too many uninsured Vermonters put off seeing the doctor because their out-of-pocket costs are so high. That puts too much reliance on expensive emergency room care, the cost of which ends up being passed to those who have coverage in the form of higher insurance premiums.
o       Vermonters spend almost 20% of their total earnings on health care and the state budget spends almost 25% on health care. The rest of the world spends only 6-12% of national income on health care yet achieves better health outcomes.
·        The system is limiting Vermonters’ control, choice and quality of care.
o       Insurance company bureaucrats deny patients the treatment they need, and insurance companies have free rein to raise Vermonters’ insurance rates without any transparency or accountability.
o       Doctors and hospitals are forced to spend too much time on paperwork at the expense of time on patient care.
·        Vermonters don’t get the most value for their health care dollars.
o       We spend too much on administration and other costs that do nothing to help Vermonters stay healthy.
o       While we spend more than other countries, we do not achieve the same health outcomes as other universal health care systems around the world.
o       We could get more and spend less.



Q. Why is H. 202 the right thing to do?
  • This plan puts the “care” back in “health care.”  It allows health care professional focus on helping patients instead of tracking down payments.
·        The plan provides our best chance to control overall health care cost.  Most Vermonters and employers could pay less.  In fact, in the first year it is implemented (some years out) the plan will save hundreds of millions of dollars. 
·        The new system will be fairer than our current system. It will ensure that all Vermonters have access to essential health benefits including primary care, preventative care, chronic care, acute care, and hospital services.  Everybody pays in and everybody benefits.
·        H.202 is an economic development and job creator.  A universal health care system will create as many as 5,000 new jobs as it reduces costs to businesses, allowing employers to reinvest that cost into growing their businesses.

Q.  What does H.202 do?
H.202 helps control health care costs and improves access to health care by:
·        Creating the health benefit exchange
·        Creating Green Mountain Care, a universal health care system that will provide health care to all Vermont residents.
·        Creates the Green Mountain Care Board to implement cost savings, and negotiate benefits and payments in a universal health care system.

Q. How will the quality of care Vermonters receive be improved?
  • All Vermonters will have access to primary care which will help Vermonters focus on staying healthy and treating minor health problems before they become big problems.
  • Green Mountain Care will ensure that all Vermonters—including children and seniors—have access to the basic care they need to stay healthy and to recover when health problems arise.
  • Many Vermonters will see their benefits package greatly improve, providing them access to primary care, preventative care, chronic care, acute care, and hospital services.
  • Doctors and health care providers will spend less time on bureaucratic paperwork and have more time to spend with their patients

Q. How does H.202 control costs?
The House Health Care amendment controls health care costs in several ways:
·        It will reduce unnecessary administrative costs that don’t contribute to patient care and will maximize our potential to save money through reforming our payment system so we reform health care delivery and pay for quality of care, not quantity of care.
·        By creating a health benefit exchange to create more uniformity in the health insurance markets and by beginning to reduce administrative costs.
·        By increasing public transparency and input in the rate review process by having insurers provide consumers with plain language summaries of rate increases over 5 percent and by giving consumers a way to comment to BISHCA when their insurance rates go up.

Q.  How is the House Health Care Committee version different from the Governor’s proposal?
·        The Green Mountain Care board is more accountable and more independent.  Nominations must be made through a nominating committee similar to the judicial nominating process.
·        The process for moving forward is more clearly defined and has clearer check-ins and approval processes.  A financing plan and Green Mountain Care budget would need to be enacted into law prior to implementation.
·        Public input is required in development of the Green Mountain Care benefit package and financing plan.

Q. Will Vermonters still be able to choose their own doctor?
Yes.  Green Mountain care preserves patient choice of provider.  It also builds on the Blueprint for Health’s emphasis on connecting Vermonters to a primary care doctor.  Vermonters will continue to receive the quality and choice of care they like in the current system.

Q.  How is this good for employers?
Green Mountain Care provides health benefits to all Vermonters – regardless of whether their employer chooses to offer insurance.  It would eliminate the unfair competition between employers who offer health insurance and those who choose not to.  It will also lower the overall costs of health care for Vermonters.  The bill does not tell employers what to do or what they have to offer for benefits.

Q.  Who is eligible?
  • All Vermont residents are eligible for Green Mountain Care. 
  • Residents of neighboring state would not be able to cross the border to get free care.  Any non-resident who receives health services in Vermont would be billed for the care they receive.

Q. How does Green Mountain Care impact…
  •  Retirement benefits? Green Mountain Care does not require employers to change their practices. Vermont retirees would be eligible for Green Mountain Care regardless of whether their employer offers benefits.  Green Mountain Care would be a secondary benefit to any existing retirement benefit.
  •  Medicare?  Medicare benefits are not touched.
  • Union-negotiated benefits? Employers and unions may continue to bargain to offer benefits if they choose to.
  • Medicaid? Medicaid and Dr. Dynasaur benefits will not be changed.  Medicaid will not be able to offer benefits that are lower than Green Mountain Care.
  • When Vermonters are out of state?  Vermont residents will remain eligible when they are temporarily out of state.  The Secretary of Administration is required to look at the following issues for Green Mountain Care and report back to the general assembly January 15, 2012 with recommendations: 
  •  Young adults under age 26 whose parents live in Vermont
  • College students going to school in Vermont 
  •  How to get health care when you are out-of-state
  • What type of out-of-state provider networks are available to Vermonters

Q.  Are we moving too fast?
We will spend an additional $1.6 billion per year by 2015 – we can’t afford to wait.  There is near universal agreement that our system is broken and must be reformed.  H.202 takes the first steps toward a multi-year process of reforming the health care system.  The House Health Care (HHC) committee’s amendment includes check points along the road to reform – this allows the general assembly to make sure reform is headed in the right direction, at the right speed. For example, some of the check points include:
·        Reports to the general assembly for major decisions, such as benefits or payment methodology changes
·        Approval by the general assembly of budgets and financial issues
In addition, this is a multi-year process, starting with an health benefit exchange in 2014 (required by federal law) – which gives individuals and small employers better access to private health insurance plans in an easy to compare format.
Q. Why does H. 202 not include a financing plan?
Done correctly, a reformed health care system will cost less than our current system.  We already have a complicate and inequitable financing system and there is no doubt that we can create a new one that is more fair.
We could develop a financing plan more quickly if we want it to be less accurate and limit opportunity for Vermonters, including employers, to participate in creating it.  To be accurate, a financing plan must be based on accurate information about the benefit package, reimbursement rates, federal participation and other factors.  The House Health Care Committee required the Administration to conduct a public engagement process to include Vermonters in the development of a financing plan.
Q. Why would the federal government give Vermont a waiver from the federal Affordable Car Act (ACA)?

President Obama has already said that he supports states in exploring innovative ways to achieve the goals of the ACA.  Green Mountain Care does this.  It helps control health care costs and improves access to health care. 


Legislative Report - 2/20/11

The House Natural Resources and Energy Committee is still in the middle of revising H.56, the Vermont Energy Bill of 2011.  We continued to take testimony on the feasibility and benefits of several biomass energy projects that are being proposed.  Major factors are the efficiency of the plants, the net available low-grade wood above and beyond the amount currently being consumed by the existing Ryegate and McNeil plants, and the impact on electric rates overall.  Biomass plants are considered baseload generators, i.e. they are online continuously to feed power into the grid.  Therefore, they are desirable for their reliability.  They also contribute to creation of jobs in constructing and running the facility as well as in forestry.

H.155, Property-Assessed Clean Energy (PACE) Districts, is also under consideration.  This bill will allow municipalities to opt into the program via a popular vote and administer the program on their own or joined with other municipalities with the help of Efficiency Vermont.  PACE will allow municipalities to provide loans to homeowners for improving the energy efficiency of their homes and for installing renewable energy systems.  These loans would be associated with the property, and they would be repaid via the property tax bill.  If the property is sold, the loan repayment would be assumed by the buyer.  Because of objections from Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac with the original PACE legislation that could allow this lien to take precedence over mortgages, H.155 makes the PACE loan secondary to the primary mortgage and any pre-existing liens.  The effect of PACE is to amortize the up-front costs of energy improvements over a long period of time.

We are also taking testimony on H.19 and H.145, both of which address the problem of carryout bags in the waste stream.  H.19 would ban the use of plastic carryout bags altogether.  H.145 includes not only plastic bags but all disposable carryout bags, but proposes a $.10/bag fee at the checkout counter to encourage consumers to bring their own reusable bags as long as consumers continue to depend on the disposable bags.  Of this fee, $.09 would flow to Vermont’s general fund, and the retailer would keep $.01.

H.46, a bill which I co-sponsored and that describes the protocol schools must follow when a physician, advanced practice registered nurse, physician’s assistant, athletic trainer or physical therapist believes an athlete may have a concussion, was passed by the House and sent to the Senate. The bill proposes to ensure that a youth athlete suffering or suspected to be suffering from a concussion or other head injury does not participate in school athletic activities until the student has received an examination by and written permission to participate from a licensed health care provider trained in the evaluation and management of concussions and other head injuries.  State guidelines and instructional materials that educate coaches, youth athletes and their parents or guardians about the nature and risks of concussions and other head injuries will be developed as well.

I am continuing to hold Meet Your Representative sessions every second and fourth Monday of the month from to and from to at the Town office.  I invite you to stop by and share your thoughts and opinions about your concerns.  You can also contact me by phone at 425-3960 or email me at myantachka.dfa@gmail.com.

Legislative Report - 2/10/2011

Now that the Legislature has been in session for over a month, there have been about 200 bills introduced. Since the deadline for submitting bills is February 24, there will probably be hundreds more submitted. Since we can’t keep track of the details of all the bills that are introduced, many of which will not even be voted out of committee, we rely on our colleagues in other committees to evaluate, modify and recommend the bills in their purview, while we concentrate on legislation before our own committees. Bills that are controversial, or that have ardent opponents as well as supporters, will be debated on the House floor before they are voted on.

On the Natural Resources and Energy committee we have been working primarily on H.56, the Vermont Energy Bill of 2011. This bill addresses four major elements of Vermont’s energy policy: 1) the SPEED program and Renewable Portfolio Standard, 2) the Standard Offer Program, 3) the Net-Metering program, and 4) the funding mechanisms for encouraging renewable energy resources.

SPEED stands for Sustainably Priced Energy Enterprise Development. It sets the goals for the percentage of Vermont’s electrical energy production from renewable resources, such as efficiency improvements, wind, hydro, solar, farm methane and biomass, as well as limiting the impact on consumer prices as we transition to those technologies. In 2004 the SPEED program called for 20% of Vermont’s power needs to be met by qualified renewable energy resources. H.56 seeks to increase this goal to 33% from in-state production alone by 2021. The intent is to generate jobs in Vermont as well as to supply us with clean energy.

The Standard Offer program guarantees certain rates that utilities can charge for the power generated from in-state renewable energy plants of 2.2 megawatts (2.2 MW) or less that constitute qualifying small-power production facilities. For example, the new solar farm in Ferrisburgh produces 1 MW of power output. In addition, the standard offer limits the cost increases for ratepayers, i.e. consumers, to 1% per year (down from the 2% limit set in the current standard offer program), and the Public Service Board is authorized to allocate the percentage distribution of different types of renewable energy under the standard offer. The current standard offer limits qualifying projects statewide to 50 MW total to ensure that electric rate increases do not exceed the 2% limit.

Net-metering is the program that allows individuals or groups to be credited by utilities for electricity they generate from solar photovoltaic or wind generators. Such installations run the electric meters backward and lower the energy consumed from the electric grid. Net-metering also allows a utility to pay customers for the electricity they generate. H.56 will extend this program into the future.

The financial assistance required to kick-start renewable energy projects has been provided from the Clean Energy Development Fund (CEDF), which has been funded from an assessment on the power produced by Vermont Yankee. If VY closes in 2012, another source of funding for the CEDF will have to be found. H.56 proposes a monthly surcharge of $1.50 per meter for this purpose. In addition to the CEDF, H.56 proposes to set up a Renewable Energy Investment fund to provide start-up assistance to projects greater than 2.2 MW, through a voluntary surcharge of 0 to 5% on a customer’s bill.

There are other provisions in the bill as well, and, as always, the devil is in the details. We are continuing to work on H.56 to find the proper balance between encouraging renewable energy development, growing jobs and protecting consumers’ wallets. If you would like to contact me or see a copy of H.56, visit MikeYantachka.com or call me at 425-3960.

The Savvy Vermont Consumer -- From the VT Attorney General's Office

Information from Attorney General’s Consumer Assistance Program (CAP) to assist all Vermonter’s to become savvy consumers!

Consumer Alert:
          Data Privacy: CAP is warning consumers with in-home wireless internet to protect themselves from internet snoops by ensuring that they have set the encryption on their system to require a password and to block outside “snoopers”.  Read more about the steps to take to protect your information at www.uvm.edu/consumer

Entitled to a Refund?
          DIRECTV:  Under the December 2010 settlement with DIRECTV, Vermont consumers may be eligible for a refund if they had a DIRECTV billing problem as a result of charges for service, including differences in advertising and actual billing for programs, cancellation fees, or extended contract charges.  The charge must have occurred after January 1, 2007 and not already been refunded.  To be eligible, consumers must file a Refund Request Form by June 9, 2011, if they have not previously filed a complaint with CAP.  Information and a Refund Request Form can be obtained by calling CAP at 800-649-2424.

CAP Monthly Motto:
“To save a dime, take the time, and check your monthly billing statements”
CAP has seen an increase in complaints of unauthorized charges being added to consumer’s monthly bills.  Unauthorized charges are appearing on telephone bills, fuel bills as well as credit card statements.  Savvy consumers review their billing statements regularly, even those they receive on line, to check for unauthorized charges and billing errors. Find unauthorized charges? Call CAP at 800-649-2424 or file a complaint at www.uvm.edu/consumer

Updates- Pyrofax
CAP received a number of complaints in December and January regarding a minimum usage fee assessed by Pyrofax. The company has agreed to refund any fees paid and does not have plans for an assessment in 2011.  Consumer Fraud Rule 111 places requirements on Vermont’s propane gas suppliers, including the disclosure of fees and adequate notice of fees. Consumers with questions about propane service fees, disconnections and refunds can contact CAP at 800-249-6464. NOTE: The price of propane gas or other heating fuels is not regulated.  

Consumer Information
          Considering buying a car, hiring a contractor, signing up with a debt settlement company, giving to a charity or wondering if a phone call, letter or email is a scam?  The CAP website has important information for consumers on all of these consumer topics and can answer consumer questions.  To access information or file a complaint go to: www.uvm.edu/consumer

CAP Monthly Top Complaint Areas:
1. Fuel    2. Motor Vehicles    3.  Credit  4.  Entertainment    5. Housing

Legislative Report - 1/23/2011

For the past two weeks the legislative session has been in full swing with several major newsworthy events taking place.  The biggest event was the report of Dr. William C. Hsiao and the Health Care System Design Study Commission.  Dr. Hsiao presented a summary of the report before the legislature and the commission’s recommendation that a system of a public-private single-payer system would be most effective in lowering costs while providing access to basic health care to all Vermonters.  His presentation as well as the draft of the full report can be found at the Joint Fiscal Office website, http://www.leg.state.vt.us/jfo/healthcaresystemdesign.aspx.  Health care is complex, expensive, and affects everyone.  Much work will have to be done by Health committees in both the House and Senate to rigorously examine the full report and take testimony before any legislation is formulated.  Any implementation of the proposals will have to achieve these goals: 1) control health care spending which has been increasing about a million dollars per day, 2) provide coverage for the  32,000 Vermonters who have none today, and 3) reduce the cost to employers of providing coverage for their employees.  The report indicates that these goals can be accomplished and provide a model for reform on a national level.  I encourage you to read the report, or at least the presentation, and let me know what you think about it.

The Joint Fiscal Office, a non-partisan research arm of the legislature, also presented to members of the legislature an overview of the report of the Blue Ribbon Tax Structure Commission.  This report can be found at http://www.vermonttaxreform.org/wp-content/uploads/2011/01/WEB-REPORT-2.pdf.  Taxes have been a persistent issue in Vermonters’ minds, and Charlotte is no exception.  We often find Vermont compared unfavorably to our neighbor, New Hampshire, which has no income or sales tax.  As a tax preparer I hear the same comments from many of my clients.  The commission considered all the types of taxes assessed by Vermont, including the income tax, the sales tax, excise taxes, fees, and property taxes, and compared them to the other New England states and New York.  The commission found that the vast majority of Vermonters pay taxes, and that Vermont’s taxes are distributed rather evenly across income classes when considering all types of taxes together.  Taken as a percentage of household income, sales taxes are regressive with lowest 20% of incomes paying 5.5% of total income and the highest 1% paying about 0.5%.  The income tax, on the other hand, is progressive, ranging from -1% (a tax benefit) for the lowest 20% to 5.5% for the top 1%.  The property tax is slightly regressive, ranging from 3.8% for the lowest 20% to 2.2% for the highest 1%, with a bump showing the top 60-95% at about 4.2%.  The distribution of the total tax contribution at all income levels averages 9% +/- 1%.  New Hampshire, on the other hand, places the highest burden of total taxation on the lowest 20% at about 8.5% of income and the lowest burden on the top 1% at about 1.7%, relying primarily on property taxes.  The commission made several recommendations including changing from taxable income to federal adjusted gross income as the starting point for the Vermont income tax.  Assuming no increase in income tax revenues, this would allow tax rates to be lowered and permit an apples-to-apples comparison with other states’ tax rates.  

In the Natural Resources and Energy Committee we are reviewing the elements of H.56, the Energy Bill of 2011.  This work will continue as we take testimony from various stakeholders.