Legislative Report 5/2/2012 - The Decision Making Process

The closing days of the legislative session tend to generate a lot of floor debate in both the House and the Senate as we have seen in the news lately.  Perhaps by the time this article is published, we will have completed our work in Montpelier and will have adjourned.  Chances are, though, that a few more days will be needed to wrap up the session.

One of the reasons why the proceedings seem to invite more debate is that the bills dealing with some of the stickier, more controversial issues are left until the end.  This stands to reason since those bills are the ones on which the committees take the most testimony and which engender the most discussion in the committees.  All members of a committee have the opportunity to express their opinion on every aspect of a bill, and the initial version of a bill is rarely the version that is voted out of committee.  Because each representative serves on only one committee, we depend on the committee reports to inform our own decisions on how to vote on bills.

Since hundreds of bills are introduced during the two-year period, some bills never get voted out of committee.  However, some get added to another bill dealing with a similar issue.  This happened with a bill I introduced concerning record keeping on the part of second-hand coin and jewelry dealers.  I introduced a bill last year to address the problem of burglaries and car break-ins so that police would have an easier time tracking down stolen property that was pawned off at these legitimate dealers.  While my bill was not acted on, a similar bill dealing with scrap metal dealers was approved.  With the help of Senators Richard Sears and Bill Cariss, elements of my bill were added to the scrap metal bill in the Senate.

One of the lessons I learned working in the legislature is that the most controversial issues may seem cut and dry, black and white, to proponents and opponents.  But once they are examined in detail with testimony from each side, with analyses from experts, and with serious discussion in committee, it becomes obvious that there are many shades of gray.  This is true of the immunization issue, the choices in dying issue, the CVPS/GMP merger, the pros and cons of different types of renewable energy, and many others.  Legislators hear from many interest groups as well as individuals urging us to vote one way or the other.  It is our job to weigh these interests based on as many facts as we can gather.  Political philosophies are certainly a factor, as are the interests of the communities we represent.  Sometimes we will come down on one side of the question; sometimes we will try to craft a compromise if it seems both sides have merit; and sometimes we will agree not to take any action if there is too much uncertainty. 

There is much left to consider and vote on this week, and it will not be unusual for our floor sessions to run late.  But democracy requires that every issue be open to debate and every legislator that wants to be heard is allowed to be heard.  When we are finished, we hopefully will have done well for the people of Vermont.

The Word in the House 4/23/2012 - The End Game

As the session heads into the last week, it really requires a scorecard to figure out what is happening to some legislation.  Bills passed by the House and sent to the Senate have seen changes to essential elements.  The same has happened to some bills sent to the House by the Senate.  Bills that were passed with different provisions by each body are now in conference committees consisting of three House members and three Senate members to see if the differences can be ironed out to the satisfaction of both.  As we begin the last weeks of the session, some bills may even die for lack of action.  Here are some of the bills that have passed both the House and Senate in recent weeks. 

Conserved land is an important asset for Vermont.  The Conservation Easement bill, S.179, strengthens the ability to protect conserved land from being developed.  When a property owner conveys a perpetual easement for conservation purposes to a town, a conservation group or another entity, that easement persists even if the property changes ownership.  If the terms of the easement are violated, S.179 allows the holder of the easement to take the violator to court with or without the participation of the owner.  Another provision of the bill creates a working group to study the issues around amending a perpetual conservation easement when situations or conditions affecting the easement change over time.  S.179 was passed by the House with amendments and has been sent back to the Senate for its agreement.

Another Senate bill, S.106, increases civil penalties that towns can charge for violations of municipal ordinances and by-laws.  It also repeals an 1876 law making towns responsible for damage done by dogs to livestock.  The House amended the bill by adding a section on embezzlement which asks the State Auditor to design a checklist that will act as a tool to help establish the internal controls for counties, municipalities, and supervisory unions.  This provision also requires Town Treasurers to file quarterly financial reports with their selectboard or city council.  The State Auditor will be required to post on the official website a summary of all financial fraud against any agency of the state.  If the Senate does not approve these amendments, the bill will go to a conference committee. 

A bill that saw some floor debate last week was S.237 relating to the establishment of a Genuine Progress Indicator (GPI).  This is an interesting proposal that has the potential to give policy makers additional information beyond the Gross State Product, which is a measure of goods and services produced statewide.  The GPI adjusts the Gross State Product by quantifying the positive and negative economic, environmental, and social impact of economic activity on the well-being and long-term prosperity of our state's citizens.  S.237 gives approval for the state’s Joint Fiscal Office to cooperate with the Gund Institute for Ecological Economics at UVM to establish and test a GPI measurement system.  All work will be done by the Gund Institute which will report back to the legislature with its results.  No state monies are involved.

There are several key bills that still need to be finalized by the House and Senate before we can adjourn.  These include the Transportation bill, the Capital Adjustment bill (regarding buildings and services), and the Budget.  We hope to adjourn sometime during the first week of May.

Legislative Report 4/18/2012 - Immunizations Revisited

One of the most controversial bills to come out of the legislature this session has been the Immunization bill, S.199.  The question it addresses is under what circumstances, if any, should a child be allowed to attend a public school or a day care facility without having received the age-appropriate vaccinations required by the Vermont Department of Health. 

On the one hand, there is the issue of protecting the public, especially children, from outbreaks of dangerous communicable illnesses as a result of low vaccination rates.  On the other, there is the concern of many parents that some vaccines present a higher risk for serious illness than the diseases they are meant to prevent.  Another aspect of the debate is whether the statistics showing an increase in the percentage of children who enter school "unvaccinated" accurately portray the situation. 

I have been following the debate on this issue very closely, paying attention to the concerns on both sides of the issue.  I have been fortunate to get input not only from constituents, medical professionals and parent advocates, but also from members of the House Health Care Committee on all aspects of the immunization debate.  They have taken testimony and discussed it in great depth.  I believe the committee came up with alternative language that recognizes the necessity of immunizations for maintaining public health as well as the concerns that some parents have regarding certain vaccines.

The vaccination rates for all the required vaccines except chicken pox are more than 90% statewide.  The chicken pox, or varicella, vaccine is at 87%.  However, while the data may show satisfactory rates of immunization for specific vaccines overall, there are pockets of the state where vaccine rates are critically low and need to be increased to keep both children and immune-compromised adults safe.  The House Health Care Committee, after consultation with school nurses as well as parents and doctors, decided to rely on education rather than a mandate and included a $40,000 appropriation for that purpose.

The committee's amendment will retain the philosophical exemption, but will require parents to consult with their pediatrician and acknowledge that they have been informed of the risks of not having their children immunized by signing a form.  Recognizing that the statistics showing decreased immunization rates do not distinguish between rejection of all vaccines and rejection of one or two, or postponement of a vaccine, the bill requires two more years for reporting of vaccination rates among school-age children.  In addition to K and 7, statistics for 1st and 8th grade will also be reported to the VT Dept of Health by each school.

It is my firm opinion that vaccines are crucial to preserving the public health and that government has a responsibility to promote their use even to the point of requiring them.  Since the main objective is to increase the overall rates of immunization, however, I support S.199 with these modifications because I believe that it addresses the immunization issue with the proper balance.

The Word in the House 4/9/2012 - Working Landscapes

The defining characteristic of Vermont is its rural nature and the connection Vermonters have to their environment.  The Working Lands Enterprise Investment Bill, H.496, passed by the House recently, recognizes this relationship and provides support to stimulate a concerted economic development effort on behalf of Vermont’s agriculture and forest products sectors.  It will assist entrepreneurism, business development, and job creation in these sectors.

Vermont is currently in the midst of an agricultural renaissance and is at the forefront of the local foods movement.  Much of this activity takes place in our own communities of Charlotte, Hinesburg, and surrounding towns.  The conversion of agricultural and forest products into value-added products within Vermont’s borders represents further economic and employment opportunities.  About 7,000 jobs exist in the forest products sector and about 57,000 are related to the food system.

H.496 makes an investment in Vermont’s working landscape by creating the Working Lands Enterprise Fund and a Working Lands Enterprise Board.  The fund, initially appropriated at $2.1 million, will be used for direct investment in working lands enterprises.  Approximately $550,000 will provide grants to entrepreneurs, including grants to leverage private capital, to jump-start new businesses, to help beginning farmers access land, and to support diversification projects to add value to farm and forest commodities.  Another $350,000 is allocated for “wrap-around” services to growth companies, including technical assistance, business planning, and financing required by companies ready to transition to the next stage of growth.  $800,000 is included for state infrastructure investments, including investment in private and non-profit sectors for creative diversification projects and value-added manufacturing, processing, storage and distribution.  Finally, about $382,000 is allocated for administration by the Agency of Agriculture.

The Working Lands Enterprise board would oversee and administer the fund and coordinate the enterprise development efforts throughout the state.  In addition to promoting the activities described above, it would also establish and evaluate criteria and benchmarks for investments and solicit appropriate perspectives and information from experts.  The board will replace the Agriculture Innovation Center which had similar but more limited responsibilities.

The investment in Vermont’s working landscape will ensure that Vermont will retain its rural and natural character and will continue to represent the vision that people associate with our state, contributing to the tourism sector of our economy in the process. 

On the redistricting front, there were changes to both the House and Senate redistricting plans that affect Charlotte and Hinesburg.  After much deliberation and review of the deviations from the ideal district sizes, the House Government Operations committee presented their final version of the redistricting plan.  One of the changes was the expansion of the section of Hinesburg attached to the Charlotte house district.  In this final version the southwestern portion of Hinesburg bordered by Drinkwater Rd, Baldwin Rd, and the Monkton town line with 33 residents will remain in the Charlotte district.  The rest of Hinesburg will comprise the other district.

The Senate finally voted its reapportionment plan out of its Government Operations committee.  In order to balance the population changes, Chittenden County had to cede part of its population to Addison County.  The new plan joins Huntington and Buels Gore to the Addison County senatorial district instead of Charlotte, which will remain in the Chittenden County senatorial district.

Legislative Report 4/5/2012 - An Energy Roadmap

Last year the legislature enacted an energy bill that continued a policy of supporting the renewable energy industry in Vermont.  This year our House Natural Resources & Energy committee spent a good deal of time working on another energy bill (H.468) that creates a roadmap for the next 20 years to extend Vermont's leadership in energy policy in order to reduce greenhouse gas emissions and promote job growth in the renewable energy industry.  It sets a goal of achieving 75% of Vermont's total electric energy from renewable sources by 2032 and includes a Renewable Portfolio Standard (RPS) of 35% new renewables by 2032, including 10% from small-scale, distributed projects.

Up to now the renewable energy goals were only goals.  Vermont utilities have been making good progress increasing their renewable portfolios so that Vermont can today count almost 50% of the electric energy we consume as renewable.  This includes the energy we get from Hydro Quebec. Two utilities, Burlington Electric and Washington Electric Co-op, are at or near 100% renewable.  By adopting a Renewable Portfolio Standard, each utility will be required to have a percentage of the electricity it sells to be renewable, including the renewable attributes, from a source built since January 1, 2005.  The percentage increases from 4% by 2017 to 35% by 2032.  (Hydro Quebec power does not count toward the 35%.)

Renewable attributes, also known as renewable energy credits or RECs, are tradable commodities associated with renewable energy and have a cash value.  Under the SPEED program, a utility that owns a renewable energy plant can sell its RECs, thereby reducing the cost of the electricity to its customers while still counting them toward their Vermont goals.  Meanwhile, the utilities buying the RECs also counted them in their portfolios.  Vermont happens to be the only state that allows this double-counting to occur.  This has the effect of undermining renewable energy development in the region because other states can satisfy their RPS requirements by buying RECs from Vermont.  The RPS will correct this situation by gradually requiring ownership of the RECs by Vermont utilities.

A key component of the RPS is an expansion of the Standard Offer program, which guarantees long-term, stable prices for renewable energy generation.  The Standard Offer program is currently capped at 50 megawatts (MW) of distributed renewable energy generation but will grow to 150 MW over 10 years. The annualized growth of 10 MW/year for 10 years sets an achievable pace that creates price stability, avoids boom/bust cycles, and benefits from decreasing renewable energy prices over time.

Finally, the bill requires the Department of Public Service to analyze and report on the status of the retail electricity market in Vermont and the effects of the SPEED and Standard Offer programs on the market, on renewable energy generation, and on greenhouse gas emissions, and to make recommendations for changes to the programs if indicated.  The bill passed 91-46 and is now in the Senate.

On another topic, the miscellaneous tax bill passed in the House on a vote of 125-14. The bill includes a repeal of the double counting of interest and dividends for income sensitivity.  However, it maintains the $500,000 cap on homestead property value for income sensitivity.  During the presentation of the bill on the floor I voiced support for the repeal of the income calculation but objected to not repealing the $500,000 cap which affects many Charlotte residents whose home values have risen disproportionately to their incomes.

The Word in the House 3/29/2012 -- Tanning Beds & Rx Databases

If you’ve ever watched a foot race, you know that as two runners in a dead heat approach the finish line, they go all out and sprint to the finish!  Something similar happens in the legislature when “crossover day” is in sight.  Crossover is the point in the legislative session when any bill that has a chance of passage on the floor of the House or Senate must be voted out of committee.  Any bill that doesn’t make this cut is dead for the session.  As you can imagine, this results in a flurry of bills that have been worked on for weeks finally being sent to the floor for a vote.  Crossover happened on March 16th, so this past week saw dozens of bills reach the House floor for a vote, and almost all were passed and sent to the Senate for that body’s consideration.  Likewise, the House will be taking up bills that were passed by the Senate in the weeks to come. 

One of the bills that was passed is H.157 relating to restrictions on tanning beds.  The impetus for this bill is the recognition that cases of melanoma have increased dramatically both nationally and in Vermont over the past few decades.  While melanoma affects Vermonters of all ages, it is the number one cancer among young adults aged 25 to 29 and is one of the most frequent malignancies among teenagers.  Indeed, Vermont has one of the highest per capita melanoma rates in the country, 29 cases per 100,000 versus 26.5 per 100,000 for the U.S.

Indoor tanning during youth appears to be particularly dangerous.  The use of indoor tanning before the age of 30 increases a person’s melanoma risk by 75%.  Since 1998, the number of teens reporting the use of tanning beds nationally rose from 1% to 27%.  In Vermont 21% of teens reported using tanning beds.  For this reason H.157 makes it unlawful for a tanning facility or operator to allow any person who has not yet reached the age of 18 to use any tanning equipment. 

Any tanning facility violating this law is subject to a civil penalty of $500 for the first violation up to $1500 for the third and subsequent violations.  The bill also allows an exemption for use of this type of equipment by a licensed physician for medical purposes or by a person who owns tanning equipment exclusively for personal, noncommercial use.

Another important bill is H.745 relating to Vermont’s prescription drug monitoring system.  Prescription drug abuse has been a growing problem in Vermont.  It has led to increased crimes of prescription fraud as well as crimes of theft by addicts in an attempt to fund their habits.  Doctors and pharmacists play an unwitting role when abusers shop doctors for multiple prescriptions and have them filled at multiple pharmacies.

The purpose of H.745 is to maximize the effectiveness and appropriate utilization of the Vermont prescription monitoring system to prevent the abuse of controlled substances without interfering with the legal medical use of those substances while providing opportunities for treatment for abusers of these substances.

The bill requires the prescription to include the date of birth of the individual as well as the quantity of the substance written in both numerical and word form to prevent quantities from being changed.  Prior to dispensing a prescription for a controlled substance, a pharmacist must require the individual receiving the drug to provide a signature and show valid and a current government-issued photo ID as evidence that the individual is the patient for whom the prescription was written, the owner of the animal for which the prescription was written, or the bona fide representative of the patient or animal owner. If the individual does not have valid, current government-issued photographic identification, the pharmacist may request alternative evidence of the individual’s identity, as appropriate. 

Prescription data is maintained in the Vermont Prescription Management System (VPMS) database maintained by the Department of Public Safety.  The bill allows specially authorized law enforcement investigators to request access to VPMS from the Commissioner of Health when abuse is suspected, but only if they have obtained a warrant.  This protects patients, doctors and pharmacists from unreasonable access to their data by investigators.